How do I evaluate a GEO agency before hiring?

Ask to see one complete example: the customer question, the original answer, the page change, the checks before launch and a later result. Then confirm who does that work for your business and what the price includes.

Apply it to your business

Review the actual questions, countries, products and source URLs in the example. Confirm CMS access, delivery responsibility, reporting cadence and costs. A clear definition of what cannot be measured is a useful sign of reporting discipline.

Reference: Our measurement method. Editorial review: 21 September 2026.

Ask to see one complete piece of work

Choose one customer question and ask the agency to walk through it from the first observation to the later result. The record should show the question, market, date, answer surface and cited pages. Next, ask which page changed, why that change was chosen and how it was tested. Finally, look at what happened after publication. An unchanged answer is still a valid result. A presentation that skips the starting evidence or shows only the winning screenshot makes the work harder to assess.

Compare responsibility as well as recommendations

A useful recommendation is only part of the engagement. Establish who edits the site, who checks factual claims, who approves a release and who can restore the previous version. Ask whether technical work is included or handed back to your developer. Give competing agencies the same example and compare their responses. You are looking for clear responsibility and useful reasoning, rather than the largest list of technical terms. Confirm which search products are observed; an API answer and a consumer search result are different measurement surfaces.

Make proof relevant to your business

A marketplace sales result can demonstrate marketplace experience, but it does not establish a GEO outcome. Likewise, a citation for an informational question may not demonstrate that a brand is recommended for a buying decision. Ask what the example proves, what it does not prove and how closely it matches your category. Prime Team’s proposed work should be assessed using the same questions. Agree on the priority questions, reporting detail and implementation scope before committing to a managed plan.

A practical check

Request one change record with the original page, the proposed edit, the staging checks and a later observation. Ask what stayed unchanged as well as what improved.

Your next questions